Why the sow was muddy. A magpie is punished by his master, who throws him into a mud puddle. The magpie sees a muddy sow. He says, "You also must have had a quarrel with your master."

Motif

Why the sow was muddy. A magpie is punished by his master, who throws him into a mud puddle. The magpie sees a muddy sow. He says, "You also must have had a quarrel with your master."

The wise and the foolish. · Fools (and other unwise persons). · Absurd lack of logic. · Logical absurdity based upon certain false assumptions. · view the constellation · filed as J2211.2

ask the rhapsode about this motif →

Scholars’ trail — 2references

The index’s own references — the collections where scholars sighted this story-shape, tradition by tradition. Titles on our shelf are live links; the rest is the frontier, not yet shelved.

U.S.Baughman.
general Pauli (ed. Bolte) No. 669

Within the index

Filed under Differences in animal nature overlooked.

Filed beside it

Frogs reprove ass for lamenting when he falls into morass. "What would you do if you had to live here always?"The murderous master. Dogs flee from their master because in time of famine he has killed his cattle. If he kills the cattle, he will surely kill the dogs Ass brays on hearing a conch shell. Owner thinks he must have been a saint in a former life

Carried in tale types

The Talking Parrot (previously Magpie Tells why Sow is Muddy) · ATU 2371 recorded variant

wander