μῦθοι Mythoi
Motif

Transformation combat. Fight between contestants who strive to outdo each other in successive transformations.

Magic. · Transformation. · Miscellaneous transformation incidents. · Repeated transformation. · view the constellation · filed as D615

ask the rhapsode about this motif →

Attested across traditions
On our shelf — the index’s citations, resolved to served chapters
The motif on our shelf — written from the served texts; every claim cited  receipt

A hero wrestles for a bride and finds his opponent will not hold still. In Apollodorus's Library — a Greek mythography compiled in the 1st or 2nd century CE — Hercules comes to Calydon to woo Deianira and "wrestled for her hand with Achelous", the river-god, "who assumed the likeness of a bull". The grip closes, the shape slides away, and the match is decided by mutilation rather than pin: "Hercules broke off one of his horns." The river-god's whole armory of forms survives only in the editor's note, where Sir James Frazer (1854–1941), the Scottish classicist whose translation carries this text, records after Ovid that the god "turned himself first into a serpent and then into a bull" — the true signature of the motif, a fighter who answers each hold with a new body.

The Kalevala (Finnish oral song, compiled 1835–1849) keeps the shape in a lighter, aerial key. Fleeing the war-hosts of Northland, young Lemminkainen escapes not by strength but by shedding his skin: "Changing both his form and features" he "Quick became a mighty eagle" and soars, until "the moonlight burned his temples" and a gray-hawk overtakes him mid-flight to ask, "Art thou thinking of our combat / With the hero-heads of Northland?" Even in the sky the duel is a duel of shapes.

Far to the east the same contest turns cosmic. In Myths & Legends of China, E. T. C. Werner's 1922 compilation, the rebel monkey Sun boasts to the Buddha, "I can change myself into seventy-two different forms"; earlier, cornered by the armies of Heaven, "Sun changed his form" and slipped clean out of the net spread across the sky. The Greek and Finnish and Chinese witnesses are all wired to served text; the Egyptian Horus-and-Seth and the many Indian authorities Frazer's apparatus points to wait unread. Why does the shape-changer, in every telling, lose in the end — the horn broken, the eagle scorched, the monkey pinned beneath a mountain?

Witnesses: The Library (Bibliotheca), BOOK II, ch. VII · The Kalevala, Rune XXVIII · Myths & Legends of China, Chapter XIV

Scholars’ trail — 17references

The index’s own references — the collections where scholars sighted this story-shape, tradition by tradition. Titles on our shelf are live links; the rest is the frontier, not yet shelved.

  • GreekFrazer Apollodorus I 256 n. 3 (Hercules and Achelous) → on our shelf: The Library (Bibliotheca), BOOK II, ch. VII
  • Irish myth*Cross
  • WelshMacCulloch Celtic 110
  • FinnishKalevala rune 28 → on our shelf: The Kalevala, Rune XXVIII
  • Buddhist mythMalalasekera I 289
  • India*Thompson-Balys
  • ChineseWerner 361 → on our shelf: Myths & Legends of China, Chapter XIV
  • HawaiiDixon 90f
  • TuamotuStimson MS (T-G. 3/1001)
  • N. Am. Indian*Thompson Tales 311 n. 117e
  • Eskimo (Cumberland Sound)Boas BAM XV 220, (West Hudson Bay): Boas BAM XV 319, (Mackenzie Area): Jenness 85, (Greenland): Rasmussen II 96
  • S. Am. Indian (Eastern Brazil)Lowie BBAE CXLIII 1 434.
  • general *Penzer III 195 n. 1, 203ff., VIII 80 n. 1
  • general Mitra *The Magical Conflict in Santali, Ao Naga Folklore (Man in India IX 173–80)
  • general Chauvin V 2 No. 2, 5 No. 443, 199 No. 116, VI 86 No. 252, 110 No. 274
  • general Cosquin Études folkloriques 570ff.
  • general Köhler-Bolte I 138, 588. – Egypt: Müller 126 (Horus and Seth)
Within the index

Filed under Repeated transformation. Transformation into one form after another.

5 finer motifs beneath it
Transformation contest between magiciansTransformation contest between master and pupilTransformation combat between lover and maidMen transformed to animals fightTransformation combat between saints
Filed beside it
Goddess repeatedly transforms herselfProtean beggar: Person assumes successive forms in order to begProtean sale: man sells youth in successive transformationsRepeated transformations to deceive wives. A husband thus makes each of his many wives believe that he is always with her
Travels with
Transformation to defeat enemies. (Cf. D615.)Transformation to animals to fight. (Cf. D615)
Keeps company with — shares receipted episodes
Sun father-in-lawAnimal bribed with food. (Sop to Cerberus.)Animal as guard of person or houseGuardian animals evadedTransformation (general)Transformation: man to featherProtean beggar: Person assumes successive forms in order to begTransformation to reach difficult placeTransformation to escape difficult situationTransformation to receive foodSeed mixed with blood as love charm. (Cf. D971.)Burning magically evaded. (Cf. D1656.)

wander